The thesis “State Defense Forces and Their Role in American Homeland Security” by Lieutenant Commander Jonathan R. Pohnel, U.S. Navy, explores how State Defense Forces (SDFs)—state-controlled military units that cannot be federalized—can serve as essential assets in domestic disaster response and homeland security. The study traces the historical evolution of militias from the colonial era through the modern SDF system and examines their legal foundation under Title 32 U.S. Code §109, distinguishing them from both the National Guard and private militias. Pohnel highlights how SDFs provide low-cost, high-value manpower to assist during emergencies, citing their contributions during Hurricane Katrinaand the 9/11 attacks, where they filled critical roles in logistics, medical aid, and security when National Guard units were deployed overseas. The thesis also evaluates organizational structures, training standards, and the advantages of SDFs under Posse Comitatus exemptions, which allow them to perform domestic law enforcement support missions that federal troops cannot. Pohnel concludes that SDFs should be expanded, better funded, and integrated into homeland security frameworks to strengthen the nation’s capacity to respond rapidly to natural and man-made disasters, arguing that these state forces represent the next logical step in America’s emergency management evolution.
This historical article is available exclusively to our Patreon members at the Private Tier ($1) and above, as our way of thanking them for their incredible support in keeping StateDefenseForce.com online and thriving. Their contributions directly fund our web hosting and domain costs, our web designer and maintainer, and the dedicated staff of The Center for State Defense Force History who research, obtain, and post these valuable historical documents. Thanks to their continued generosity, we’re able to preserve and share the legacy of America’s State Defense Forces while expanding our mission to educate the public and strengthen support for these vital organizations nationwide.
Click Here to Join Our Patreon Program or Upgrade Your Membership